U-JOINT going bad???

Razzmaniac

Bought an X
So, on my 2007 X, say at about 50mph give or take 10mph. . .doesn't really matter. . . when I take my foot of the gas and then gas it up again, I hear a jerky clunk from the rear. Ive had my diff fluid changed constantly and its not that. No grinding noise as if from the bearings. Could it be the U-Joint? It doesn't happen at low or high speeds, just that intermediate speed.
 

yellowx16

Need Bigger Tires
Founding Member
Location
Rochester, NY
same exact thing happens with mine. when I let off it clunks and then when I press back on the gas it clunks again. I have always thought it was the u-joint as well, so I had those change out in the summer, and the problem still persists. I think it may be slack in the driveline, not sure where but this may be your problem as well. hopefully it is just the u-joint in your case though.
 

steve500

Test Drive
Location
Helper, Utah
Both my 05 Nismo crewcab (44k miles) did this and so does my 07 xterra offroad (100k miles- 4spider gear rear vs 2spider of the 05/06 nismo/offroad)

The clunk arrived around 57k miles in my 07 Xterra, I have never replaced the u-joints on anything yet but I think it's mostly drivetrain slack in the rear somewhere in combination of the extra leverage when 5th gear (torque converter is locked) is engaged, makes the lash of slack really exaggerated when barely letting off the throttle and reapplying throttle quickly.

My buddies brand new pro4x titan does this when coasting in 5th gear as well. I've pinned it down as normal operation and deal.

Sent from my SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
 

Prime

Shut up Baby, I know it!
Admin
Location
Denver Adjacent
That was going good to be my next question. Manual or auto? On an auto you naturally have play due to the torque converter and transmission design. It seems as though the torque converter isn't handling locking and unlocking very gracefully. And that is introducing a clunk.
 

Xado89

Skid Plates
Location
Ocala, FL
I have this same issue on my Gen 1, 00' Xterra. Ive always wondered if it was Ujoints or possible Trans issues. Sub'd just to keep informed.
 

Razzmaniac

Bought an X
Its an automatic. . .and only at that certain speed. Definitely not when put into drive or reverse, and definitely not on initial start up. So ya, I guess that would make it the torque convertor??. . .
 

Cyclemut

Wheeling
Founding Member
Location
Morrison, CO
Look at your rpm's when you do this. If you let off the gas and the r's drop pretty good, then when you step on the gas and the r's go up further than when you let off the gas (say, you're doing 50'ish and the r's are at 1500, but when you hit the gas again they jump up to 2000), then it's your transmission downshifting when you hit the gas (or the torque converter unlocking and allowing the higher rpm's).

If the rpm's go back to where they were (1500), then it's drivetrain slop (trans, t-case, rear diff, rear driveshaft [front u-joint or rear cv] or rear diff). You can check the rear driveshaft by shutting the engine off while in neutral, applying your parking brake (hard) and then crawling underneath the truck. Grab your shaft (insert joke here) and the rear diff yoke and twist them in opposite directions. If the shaft moves, the rear cv is going out. Do the same thing with the slip yoke at the t-case, trying to move them in opposite directions. If there's movement, then the u-joint is bad. If both are good, then try to move the shaft sideways, up, down and even in and out of the t-case to see if there's any slop. If you can't find anything with those tests, then it's more than likely just normal slop either in the trans or the rear diff. If there's no howling or gravel noise coming from anywhere, drive it and be assured you checked it out pretty good. If there is noise anywhere, doesn't change with gear selection and gets incrementally louder with road speed, not engine speed, then your rear diff needs checked out.
 

Razzmaniac

Bought an X
If I turn off the O/D, it doesn't do it at all. Smooth as butter. So no clue what that is about, and yes, the rpms change when letting off and on the gas. Cycle, as far as any noise, The rear diff was supposedly rebuilt like 40k miles ago. It has a faint whine around 60mph, or so and sometimes doesn't whine at all, Usually after ive had it in 4wd. No clue about that either. Anyway, ive had a few mechanics look at it, no leak, apparently no movement in the driveshaft and I have the rear diff fluid changed with every oil change and every time, the fluid is clear, and no signs of shavings or metal. So that's a good sign.
 

Cameron23

Skid Plates
Founding Member
Location
Kansas
I have the same problem with my 01 except the noise seems more towards the front. I figured it could be engine mounts. Also am I supposed to have my diff fluid changed with every oil change?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Muadeeb

Nissan al Gaib
Admin
Location
Dallas
I have the same problem with my 01 except the noise seems more towards the front. I figured it could be engine mounts. Also am I supposed to have my diff fluid changed with every oil change?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No, it only needs inspection every 30k. But do change it if you've done some deep water fording.

Sent via wild ferrets on crack
 
Last edited:

Muadeeb

Nissan al Gaib
Admin
Location
Dallas
Depending on how they're bad, when the engine torques itself, it may also be moving slightly fore/aft, causing the driveshaft to try to compress or expand. Tranny and transfer are pretty well attached to the engine, but the shafts have some play in them.
 

Cameron23

Skid Plates
Founding Member
Location
Kansas
Depending on how they're bad, when the engine torques itself, it may also be moving slightly fore/aft, causing the driveshaft to try to compress or expand. Tranny and transfer are pretty well attached to the engine, but the shafts have some play in them.

This is what I am assuming my noise could be just haven't had the time to tear into it


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Top